Friday, April 11, 2014

No way to treat the elderly

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 11/2/2013
**************************
The other day a young woman took her grandfather to a mental hospital because he was unresponsive and didn’t seem to know his family.
Hospital personnel determined the 70-year-old man was not mentally ill but suffered from Alzheimer’s disease. A mental institution was no place for a person with Alzheimer’s and the admitting doctors refused to take him because the facility was ill-equipped to handle his illness. The daughter disappeared, but the hospital referred the man to another medical facility, which also refused to admit for the same reasons.
It appears that care for this poor man will not come soon. He was taken to a police station where he was fed and apparently given shelter.
Now is this any way to treat our elders?
No, of course not. But Saudi Arabia’s health care has not kept pace with the rapidly changing face of Saudi society. Our public services, or should I say lack of public services, are predicated on the family. Saudi families have long prided themselves on taking care of the elderly and infirm. When extended family members find themselves in trouble, it wasn’t uncommon for relatives to take them in.
Yet we as a society are rapidly losing these fundamental characteristics once found in families. Many families are now fractured. Divorce, unemployment, domestic abuse, our excessive reliance on social media, satellite television and video games have made Saudi families more isolated than ever while at the same time leaving less time to care for family members who need help the most.
Saudis have not caught on to the new family dynamic. As a consequence the government is not prepared to deal with families that are unwilling or unable to care for the elderly and the sick in their own home.
Granted, the Saudi population of people over the age of 64 is just 3 percent, but the life expectancy of the average Saudi man is 72.4 years old and for woman 76.5 years old. This is a dramatic increase from the average life expectancy of 50 in 1974. We have also seen an increase in the elderly population jump 44.5 percent in 2004 from 1992. By 2030, we can expect an 2.5 million Saudis over the age of 65 with a life expectancy of about 80 years, according to King Saud University.
The simple facts are the elderly will be a burden on families as their parents and grandparents live longer but also have more health issues.
It is the duty and blessing of every Muslim to care for their parents and Islam stresses family support for the old, but changes in societal behavior have raised the issue that many families no longer have the wherewithal to provide around-the-clock care for a parent suffering from Alzheimer’s or is bed-ridden with other afflictions. The medical care for the old is too complex, but is expected to be carried out by family members without any significant training.
But there is no place to go for help. Unlike in other countries, Saudi Arabia has no comprehensive health care facilities that can take in the elderly. Convalescent hospitals for the elderly, nursing homes and long-term geriatric care facilities are few.
There are only 10 social centers serving less than 2,000 elderly people in the entire country, according to KSU’s 2008 study. Ninety percent of those residents have no families and no other shelter.
Accurate data is hard to come by to determine whether the lot of an old person’s life has improved in the five years since the study was conducted.
What we do know is that the mental hospital staff did not know where to send the 70-year-old Alzheimer’s victim. The idea that a police station to house and feed the old fellow was the only alternative indicates that our government agencies have not responded to this growing necessity to provide the proper care. We can expect more examples of abandoned old people as the burden becomes too great for Saudi families.

Need to prevent child abuse

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 7/2/2013
*****************************

THE most recent spate of child abuse cases that attracted considerable attention in social media outlets points to a growing frustration among Saudis about the rising number of reported incidents of violence against children in our society.
The case of a man accused of raping and murdering his five-year-old daughter and the horrific account of the systemic and gruesome violence against a nine-year-old boy should be evidence alone that we are not doing enough to protect our children.
A primary component of our society is that the family’s privacy must be protected. But privacy in the extreme does not help build a strong society and privacy can’t stand in the way of monitoring child abuse by the Ministry of Social Affairs.
We live in an era of heightened anxiety and stress. More than 60 percent of Saudis do not have their own home. Many Saudis are coping with unemployment. The cost of living continues to rise and the traffic in urban areas is almost unbearable. The stress on young parents is especially difficult.
According to Aliah Al-Fareed of the National Human Rights Commission, a significant percentage of Saudi wives are subject to violence by their husbands. A high percentage of those women are between the ages of 18 and 29. However, most of those women never went to the police.
Sanaa Al-Hwaily, a Saudi psychologist with the Ro’ea Center for Social Studies, reported that 45 percent of all Saudi children have been subjected to violence. In 2011, the center registered 500 cases of violence against children, a huge leap from 292 registered cases in 2010. She expects the numbers to increase in 2013.
The fallout from all of this is that often young children become scapegoats for their parents’ problems. It’s almost expected that reported child abuse cases increase in these difficult times. By the same token, it’s necessary that the Saudi government steps in and takes strict measures against child abusers by making it easier to report people who commit violence.
Rather than valuing privacy to the extent that it puts a child in danger, Saudi Arabia needs to consider adopting strategies from other countries that will enhance safety. In addition to an awareness campaign, the Ministry of Education should develop laws that require teachers to report suspected abuses of children to police. Foster family programs, which are nonexistent in Saudi Arabia, but commonplace in many other countries, would take abused children out of shelters and into a loving home environment. Shelters are not the only solution to protecting children. Often these shelters serve more or less as warehouses since the emotional wellbeing of the children is not a priority.
Police departments need to resist taking a passive stance in the name of privacy by actively investigating child abuse cases. In fact, law agencies must encourage reporting abuse.
We have a family in our apartment building in which the parents are constantly fighting. Often loud shouting matches go on through the night and early morning. The young children are subject to verbal abuse. Whether they are physical abused is unknown, but it usually doesn’t take long for physical violence to follow verbal violence.
Yet the police won’t investigate such cases because they need a complaint from a family member. Never mind that most victims of domestic violence will not report their abuse to authorities because they fear reprisals.
I remember when I was a child a family in my neighborhood was physically abused by the father. The screams of the mother and the children could be heard throughout the neighborhood. When the screams started, my parents would take all the children inside the house to make sure that we would not hear those screams.
The abuse became so bad that my father finally went to their house with the imam of our mosque and two other men and explained to the man who abused his wife and children that his behavior was un-Islamic in the worse way. I don’t know whether the abuse stopped after that day, but the screams did. We never heard the abuse again.
But Saudi families live isolated lives now and there are few neighbors willing to confront a child abuser about his crimes.
To address this problem, female police officers would help solve the issue of abuse victims reluctant to file complaints. Wives and mothers would feel more secure walking into a police station to file a complaint to a woman police officer.
Saudi Arabia has Naif Arab University for Security Sciences that requires police officers to attend for certification. Women attend this university to become prison guards in female prisons. There is no reason why women police officers can’t be trained with an emphasis on handling domestic abuse cases. Police departments can comply with Shariah by providing separate entrances for female officers and for women who require police services.
We can no longer hide behind our right to privacy when a child’s life is in danger. If the life of one of our neighbors is threatened and we do nothing, what does that say about us?

The lesson Rihan taught me

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 4/2/2013
*****************************

WHEN I WAS 6 years old I had a pet goat named Rihan. He was my best friend.
Rihan was the offspring of goats that belonged to my grandmother who lived not far from my family in Madinah. She gave me Rihan while my cousin received another goat.
Rihan was all mine, which meant that he was my responsibility. This is no small thing for a 6-year-old. I had to learn how to feed it, take care of its needs and make sure he had all the attention that he deserved. He was my family. I was his mother and he was my son. I raised him since he was a baby still breastfeeding from his mother.
At my house we had a huge backyard. I had my dad build a small barn to give him shelter in the corner of the yard where I grew some vegetables. During the summer my entire family slept outdoors and Rihan used to sleep under my bed. During the day and evenings we’d play in the backyard. I had a bicycle and since my parents didn’t allow me to play in the streets, I rode my bike in the big backyard with Rihan following me wherever I went.
We both loved fig rolls and Rihan followed me around always demanding more. I would eat half a fig roll and he would eat the other. He refused to stop following me until the whole package was empty.
Every other day I gave my baby a bath. He was one fat, happy and fluffy goat. For more than a year, I did little but play and care for my little buddy, whom I regarded as a family member.
Around this time my mother, who was never properly educated, had finished primary school through adult education. This was an exciting moment for the family and we decided to throw a big party and invite the extended family.
I don’t remember whose idea it was to buy Rihan from me, but my dad ultimately offered SR 200 for him. Now, SR 200 is a lot of money for a little kid, but I somehow it didn’t feel right to sell my friend. I wasn’t convinced this was the right decision, but the adults in the family put pressure on me and I didn’t want to disappoint them.
On the day of the party, my dad loaded Rihan into the back of his truck. I insisted that I go with him. I hopped into the bed of the truck and wrapped my arms around Rihan neck. I felt then, as I do now, that he knew what lay ahead for him. I tried to feed him, but he refused to take the food. I continued to hug him and nuzzle his neck, but he seemed frightened. He was not his playful self.
I had changed my mind about giving up Rihan, but it was too late to turn back. In the desert, where my family had set up a big camping site, my dad took Rihan from the truck to behind a tree. Rihan was crying. I was crying. I heard him scream while my dad slit his throat.
I cried my eyes out that day, and then fell into a deep sleep. Sometime later in the day, my mom and dad woke me up and told me to come for dinner. I didn’t want to eat, but they insisted. I sat on the ground in front of the lavish meal and ate the meat. I then threw up.
My parents offered me a new goat since my grandmother had another batch born. I refused the offer.
A goat is a goat, but in a child’s eyes that goat is something entirely different. A pet, yes, but often another member of the family. Pets teach children responsibility, but it also teaches a child love.
I was put in a position to make a decision that I was entirely unprepared to take, but I can’t really blame my parents for what happened. Adults often do not realize the importance children attach to animals and how vital animals are in a child’s small world.
When I was 12 years old, our family moved to another apartment. I owned a cat at that time, and my mother told me I couldn’t take it to our new home. I left the cat behind with regret, but it didn’t hurt the way I had lost Rihan because I always felt that I was a party to his death and suffered guilt as a consequence.
My brother, who lives in the United States, recently complained to me that my 4-year-old niece is cluttering up their apartment with too many belongings. He sent me a photo of my niece’s dolls, clothing and toys piled high in the corner of her bedroom. He asked whether he should move the stuff to the closet and throw out the worthless things.
Absolutely not, I said. They were her things and her world. It was not a decision an adult should make because he had no idea what importance she attached to certain things. Only she would know, and as a preschooler she was not likely to share with her parents what she considered her most cherished possessions.
My niece now begs my brother for a cat. He refused her, but I’m thinking that when she returns to Saudi Arabia, her aunt might just get her that cat.
I owe it to the memory of Rihan.

Youths are calling: Are we listening?

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 31/1/2013
*************************
There is a perception inside Saudi Arabia and abroad that Saudi youths are idle, humorless and disengaged from the political and societal movements in their country.
About 10 years ago my circle of friend had often complained about some men and women in our own generation whose main concern was less about developing a work ethic and becoming active in the community and more about spending time smoking sheesha, sipping coffee at outdoor cafes and cruising the Corniche.
Those are some of the Saudis of my generation that got caught between the oil boom of the 1970s and what was once called dot.com boom of the late 1990s and early 2000s. Perhaps they can best be described as Saudi Arabia’s lost generation.
Whatever path the now 40-somethings have taken is now set in stone. They have chosen their future. However, the new generation is on the cusp of dramatic change in our society. They are a far different lot. They have taken notice of their country’s strengths and failings and have turned to social media to comment. They are a generation of observers with a dynamic take on the world they inhabit.
The medium they are using is YouTube in which comedy programming is used to tackle social phenomenon in a startling way. Aish el ee, or “What is that?” is a comedy program staffed by young Saudi men. It is the top show watched throughout the Arab world because it tackles social issues in a funny way.
Sahi, or “Awake” takes on more topical issues like the fatal Jeddah floods and the work of the Jeddah municipality. Sahi is not afraid to highlight ministries that fail to complete projects. These programs are low-budget affairs recorded by Saudis in a small one-room studio. Each program runs about 10 to 15 minutes.
Ala Attair is another TV program. Commentators pick up news stories from the Arabic press and write comedy sketches that lampoon social norms, not unlike the US program, “The Daily Show with Jon Stewart.” For example, one segment discusses how drivers control women’s lives. Another may offer tips to women who need a mahram to help them conduct business. Ala Attair’s solution is to have women carrying around a male doll dressed in a thobe that is kept in a purse for emergencies.
Some programs are interspersed with other, more serious segments that include interviews with Saudis in malls. One Saudi, for example, complained to the camera that, “I have done everything … I studied hard, graduated with high marks and went to all the companies (for a job) … they accuse us of being lazy and being careless (but) I am ready, I just want a chance.”
Remarkably, some of these programs attract as many as 300 million viewers across the Middle East. The comments are often as funny as the programs and provide a window into young Saudis’ attitudes about their country, their wants and needs, and disappointments.
More important than simply entertainment, the Saudi government can learn a great deal about what young people think, especially as ministries prepare to introduce new regulations that affect society in general or more specific issues like employment. Their comedic commentaries are a constructive way to express disappointment without being confrontational.
After all, the median age of Saudis is 25 years old with nearly 30 percent under the age of 14. This should give the Saudis of my generation and my parents’ generation pause to consider that Saudis under the age of 30 are largely unrepresented in the decision-making process of the government. Public dialogue is not available to them and there are no clubs or common gathering places, other than sheesha parlors, that allow them to express ideas. It’s as if they don’t exist. Yet they are the backbone of our society. Frankly, it’s negligent to ignore this segment of society.
Behind the jokes is a real earnestness among Saudis to do the right thing for their country. They obviously love Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Abdullah and are true patriots. That’s why these programs have drawn a loyal following among millions of young people.
It’s in Saudi Arabia’s best interest to pay attention to them.


Don’t get too excited about Jeddah’s new aquarium

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 24/1/2013
*****************************
 hate to be a wet blanket, but I wonder how long it will take before someone decides that the SR 250 million aquarium on Jeddah’s Corniche is not in public interest and needs to be closed to make sure no families engage in hanky panky.
The Fakieh Aquarium is a wonderful, long overdue project that will be home to an estimated 7,000 marine animals consisting of more than 200 species. Imagine exposing thousands of Saudi and expat children to sharks, dolphins, sea lions and an up close and personal look at reefs.
But as with many good things designed to provide entertainment and education for families, there are elements in Saudi society that deem these kinds of attractions as moral corruption.
A case in point is the small dinosaur exhibit recently shut down at the Al-Othaim Mall in Dammam. Scores of families flocked to the exhibit. But according to several social media websites, sometime during the day some people burst into the exhibit area and turned off the lights. They sent panicked children and mothers racing for the exits. Some children became separated from their parents and were traumatized during the chaos. These people were alleged to be officials of the Commission for Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice (Haia).
The Haia later released a statement denying they closed down the exhibit, yet plenty of images and eyewitness accounts posted online told a different story. It seems the conservatives truly believe that having fun on a family day out can be too much of a good thing.
It’s come to the point that we as a society find ways to deprive families of having places to have fun together.
Now, wives with husbands, and mothers with fathers and their children can’t spend the day at a dinosaur exhibit without being harassed. The behavior of the some people — if indeed they are guilty of what the exhibit attendees allege — diminishes the concept of the family.
The motives for shutting down the dinosaur exhibits are murky. It could be the whole mixing thing. It also could be the exhibit covered prehistory, which sends the ultra-conservatives into a tizzy. Whatever the reasons, certain individuals in positions of religious authority treat Saudis and expats as if they are children who have no brain of their own.
It’s kind of like the silly notion that the new female members of the Shoura Council must be segregated from the men to prevent immoral behavior. Really now. The Shoura Council consists of the top minds in Saudi Arabia. Professional men and women in their 40s, 50s and 60s and possessing postgraduate degrees apparently can’t be trusted to be morally upright. When women are selected for council committees, will they be segregated as well?
Should all interaction between male and female council members be conducted via closed circuit television? It pretty much defeats the purpose of giving women an active role in Saudi society.
It’s this kind of thinking that puts public educational exhibits in jeopardy. Once moms and dads walk through the Fakieh Aquarium hand in hand with their kids in tow, someone will find it objectionable and recommend the facility’s closure.
Not long ago, it was announced that 56 Saudi children and young people won awards in eight international mathematics competitions in 2012. The children competed against the giants in science and technology: Germany, France and Italy. The kids won the first Arabic medal in physics and won distinction for solving medical and technical problems. They also performed well in international scientific and engineering forums. They competed in such prestigious competitions as the Intel International Science and Engineering Fair and the International Exchange of North America.
Those children are the result of Custodian of the Two Holy Mosques King Abdullah’s dream of a new generation of Saudis possessing knowledge. It was accomplished by dragging those kids out of the dark ages and into the 21st century.
By closing down dinosaur exhibits, and other events like book fairs and literary club readings, the more crude actors in Saudi society are simply dragging Saudis back to the dark ages.
I’m sure those so-called guardians of morality find it attractive that entire families sit in front of the television or video games getting fatter and dumber by the day instead of learning about the origins of birds, the migratory habits of dolphins or the writings of contemporary authors.
Keeping us brain-dead is the ultimate weapon of control.


New SAFF chief best man to help female athletes

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 10/1/2013
*************************************

My good friend Ahmed Eid Al-Harbi was elected last month as president of the General Assembly of the Saudi Arabian Football Federation (SAFF).
In a 32-30 vote, he beat out Khalid bin Mohammed Al-Muammar in SAFF’s first-ever election for a four-year term.
Sepp Blatter, president of the International Federation of Association Football, also known as FIFA, which supervises SAFF, said Ahmed’s election was an “achievement and an example to other Gulf states” and a “wonderful example” of how “democracy can work in the Kingdom.”
I can’t think of a better person than Ahmed to run SAFF. And I am less enamored with this moderate exercise in democracy and more impressed with the quality of the man elected to the post.
Ahmed was a top athlete in his playing days as a goalkeeper for Al-Ahli SC and served as the team’s president in 1987. He was never one of those testosterone-fueled guys strutting their stuff on the pitch, but humble, quiet and who always talked about his family first. With Ahmed, there was no tunnel vision of football as the one and only in his life. He had an expansive view of the world and what it could not only offer to athletes in general, but specifically women athletes.
Some people in the world of football see Ahmed as a reformer, but I don’t think the label does him justice. I see him as a visionary.
He is probably the single most important male ally that Saudi female athletes have to get a women’s football team up and running, and competing against international teams.
Ahmed recognizes that SAFF is much more than the umbrella group for football leagues, but can be an agent of change in Saudi society. And what I like most about these efforts to change the way the sport is played and perceived by football fans throughout the Kingdom is that the new president does it all under the radar.
His habit is to respond to any invitation to visit female universities in Saudi Arabia and help them develop women’s football teams.
He taught university administrators and instructors how to qualify for trainer positions with big-name football unions in the United States, England, Brazil and Germany. While vice president of SAFF’s player status committee, he had the federation help establish women’s physical education curriculum as an early step to combat obesity and provide a comprehensive physical education training program that will be beneficial to future athletes.
He told my husband in 2011 that he helped a female basketball and volleyball group at a Jeddah college. And by organizing women’s football teams, universities can organize leagues with an eye toward future competition in the Olympic Games.
This is real progress. While women are a long way from FIFA recognition or even hitting the playing field against a team from another country, I see the shelf life of underground female training and games having an expiration date. There will be a time when women’s leagues will be competitive, Teams like the King’s United Football Club in Jeddah will no longer play in the shadows.
Ahmed is faced with a tough sell with religious conservatives to get Saudi recognition for women’s football that will ultimately lead to international recognition. He believes the infrastructure needs to be in place to make it practical for women to play. That means new playgrounds and stadiums equipped to handle the requirements of a segregated society. The Ministry of Education should also participate to protect women’s sports while at the same time maintain our Islamic principles.
These are the obvious paths to take to ensure that women get a crack at participating in sports. But as a practical matter, women still must contend with attitudes among some Saudis that they should not be playing in front of male audiences and certainly not on television.
Ahmed recognizes these obstacles and possesses the diplomatic skills to negotiate with various parties to reach a compromise, while at the same time do not offend the sensibilities of the more conservative elements of our society. This does not come as a surprise to me or to those who are close to him because he is a strong believer in the Prince Abdullah Al-Faisal’s philosophy of sport and wisdom.
Ahmed has a full plate. Perhaps developing women’s sports programs at the SAFF level is not his priority. But if anybody can effect change, it’s Ahmed.

Prison education programs show inmates the way back into society

The column appeared originally  in Arab News dated 3/1/2013
********************************
At a recent graduation ceremony in Qassim this week, 13 individuals received their community college diplomas in human resources and information technology (IT).
Ordinarily, this type of event doesn’t generate much interest in the media. But what made the graduation ceremony unusual was the 13 graduates were prisoners incarcerated by the General Administration of Prisons (GPA).
The lucky 13 are part of a growing trend to provide higher education for convicted Saudi criminals in an effort to re-integrate them into society once they are released. This is not a particularly novel program since prisons in North America and Europe have been offering university degrees through correspondence to prisoners for decades. Yet, for Saudi Arabia, prison education programs mark significant efforts to change the path for prisoners who otherwise would be released without clear goals to lead productive lives in Saudi society.
The GPA has called on prison directors across the Kingdom to coordinate with universities to allow prisoners to pursue an education. The director of the Qassim facility said the program opens new horizons for prisoners in science, knowledge and IT as full-time university accredited courses. The director of the community college in Buraidah told a Saudi newspaper recently that college-level courses are taught in human resources and Internet technology. These are top specialties vacancies that employers routinely need to fill. College studies prepare prisoners for the outside world, and with a degree in hand transition from prisoner to a member of the Saudi labor force could be smooth. Further, it provides the prisoners’ families with a safety net that provides the opportunity to earn an income. Without an income, the potential to re-offend and return to prison is greater.
The education programs are geared for Saudis, who account for just under half of the prison population Kingdom-wide. There are 40 permanent prisons and about 60 transitional facilities housing an estimated 44,500 prisoners. Although incarcerated expatriates are not generally barred from participating in education programs, a great many are deported following their convictions and not eligible for these programs.
The education scheme is part of a continuing effort by the GPA to develop a codified system that also includes adult education programs for individuals that never finished high school, and community service and work-release programs. A relatively new program is community service, which allows prisoners to serve their sentencing by working in the community, such as cleaning mosques, aiding the elderly or volunteering to work for local traffic departments.
In addition to 11 factories that employ 2,029 prisoners for vocational training, the GPA also has 38 adult education facilities, 42 intermediate schools, 43 high schools and four schools for women. The GPA now has 296 Saudi prisoners enrolled in high education studies with 3,626 prisoners enrolled in general education courses. The GPA has 642 teachers in its ranks.
To some, especially the victims of crimes, the idea of allowing criminals to obtain a free education may seem like a reward for bad behavior. Certainly the concept of prison is punishment for bad deeds, but at the end of the day these individuals remain members of society and upon release there must be a place for them.
My father worked in the Saudi prison system for many years, and as a child he often told my brothers, sisters and I stories about the men behind bars. He warned us, of course, to consider prisoners’ stories as object lessons of what could occur if my brothers and I chose the wrong path. But the lesson I learned is that deviating from the right path was often the result of lack of education.
It is never too late to embrace education as a means to rise above unfortunate circumstances and contribute in some small way to our country. Perhaps a good example is the story of my two cousins. Both were born into difficult family circumstances and education was not necessarily a priority in their family. One cousin became involved in drugs and was lost forever. The other found a way to not only attend school, but also to go on to a university to obtain a degree. It was education that shaped my successful cousin’s destiny.
My experiences as a journalist covering the prison system over the past several years has afforded me a first-hand look at how the GPA implements its philosophy of transforming convicted criminals to productive members of society. Much of the credit goes to Maj. Gen. Ali bin Hussein Al-Harithy, director-general of the GPA, and his staff who recognize that, yes, incarceration is a means to punish offenders and protect society. But the GPA also recognizes warehousing thousands of men and women also harms society and is a terrible waste of human resources.
By investing in education, even for adults deemed by the courts as morally corrupt, we can save a great many lives. Perhaps if a higher education program was available when my cousin was in the throes of his addiction and incarceration, he might have been saved.


We can see the change, but it leaves a lot to be desired

The column appeared in Arab News 27/12/2012
************************************
A Saudi Arabia continues its reform process at a snail’s pace and granting women more rights, we hit a milestone in 2013 with 10 percent of the 150 seats in the Shoura Council going to women.
Whether this is a window dressing remains to be seen, but I have my doubts that the road to equality will suddenly be paved with gold with men throwing rose petals at our feet as we march to a greater tomorrow.
The battle to join Saudi society — really, women stand on the margins of our society and more or less wait politely to become full-fledged members — is in its infancy. Female representation in the Shoura Council will not matter much if the male chorus drowns out our right to bring up social issues that affect not only women but also the supposed core of Saudi society: The family.
Despite my doubts, I am optimistic that women will achieve a high degree of equality. I cannot bring myself to say complete equality as advocated by the West, nor do I necessarily believe that complete equality is the right thing for Saudi Arabia. What I do believe in women’s equality as defined in Islam. That means the right to work, seek an education, have the rights guaranteed under Shariah and much, much more.
Since King Abdullah implemented his reforms beginning in 2005, Saudi Arabia has much to be proud of in addition to having women on the Shoura Council.
Consider the positives:
• Women will have the right to vote and run for office in municipal elections. Whether women will vote in large numbers remains to be seen, given the sway husbands, fathers and brothers have on the women in their families. That said, what boxes someone checks off once in the voting booth will remain between the voter and her conscience.
• Saudi women can attend law schools, earn a juris doctorate, work in law firms and meet with clients. As of this moment, female lawyers are not representing men, nor are they appearing in courts before judges. I see this changing, especially in the field of family law where women face harsh discrimination.
• The Ministry of Labor has paved the way for women to be fully integrated in the retail sector. We see Saudi women working in restaurants as servers and hostesses, and in shopping malls selling cosmetics, lingerie, abayas and jewelry. They are also often the sole operators of mall kiosks.
• The Ministry of Higher Education has done a commendable job of implementing King Abdullah’s scholarship program to see that Saudis earn a graduate and postgraduate degree from universities throughout the world. Many Saudi women have taken advantage of studying in Canada, the United States, the United Kingdom and Australia. The success rate has been nothing short of extraordinary. At least 60 percent of the university graduates are Saudi women.
• The Ministry of Social Affairs is poised to issue licenses to Saudi women to open daycare centers. This is a huge leap in helping women provide the necessary childcare for working mothers.
• The Saudi government granted nearly 2,000 Saudi women permission in 2011 to marry non-Saudis, including a handful of Westerners. This provides a glimpse of the shifting attitudes of the government to encourage marriage among Saudi women who will not succumb to societal pressure to marry another Saudi. Two-thousand marriages do not sound like much, and it isn’t, but a significant change from just a decade ago.
These are achievements that I thought I would never see in my lifetime. When examined in its totality, the King’s reforms are real and have had a tremendous impact on thousands of Saudi women.
Yet obstacles remain on many levels. Most notable is the religious establishment that exploits Saudis’ weaknesses on all things Islamic. By playing on our fears that we might be less of a Muslim that they are, some religious leaders use threats and intimidation in an attempt to keep the status quo.
Consider the negatives:
• Some sheikhs routinely cast aspersions on women and the men in their family if women choose to work outside the home. Religious scholars appeal directly to the Ministry of Labor to revoke its decisions to grant women access to the workplace.
• Women are often deemed as corrupted if they study at Western universities.
• Saudi women are unable to find suitable employment after earning their university degrees. They often look outside Saudi Arabia for jobs. Qatar, Bahrain, the UAE, Oman, and even some Western countries are now benefiting from the talent of educated Saudi women, especially those in the medical field.
• Domestic law courts continue to be a minefield for Saudi women. Despite years of promises that codified laws will be in place, Saudi courts remain extremely favorable to Saudi men. Court rulings are still based on a mixture of tribal experiences and Shariah knowledge of judges. The rule of law often does not apply in divorce, custody, alimony and inheritance cases. This is a direct violation of Shariah.
• Saudi women are denied the right to drive a vehicle in urban areas. Much of this is due to the reluctance of women possessing international driving licenses to get behind the wheel and challenge society by simply driving. So they share some responsibility in their failure to achieve driving rights. However, the sorry state of public transportation and the hypocrisy of some religious leaders to insist we share a car with a driver who is an unrelated male make relative independence, not to mention finding meaningful employment, elusive.
Saudi society is in a profound state of flux, but it’s positive change. Our society cannot survive without change and without introducing half the population to the full benefits of the society we live in. The Kingdom is diversifying its economy by placing less emphasis on oil production and more on alternative energy, petrochemicals, and auto and auto parts production. At the same time, our country must also recognize that diversification means educating and employing its female population. Without the participation of women, Saudi Arabia will only achieve half its goals.


Discouraging working women

The column appeared originally in Arab News dated 20/12/2012
**************************

A couple of weeks ago Saudi women were treated to the wisdom of a man who calls himself a sheikh when he announced on social media that female fast-food workers were prostitutes.
This week another man who holds the same title said that any man who allows the women in his family to work in the health care profession is a duyooth.
Duyooth means “cuckold” and refers to weak men who allow their wives to commit adultery in front of them. And in Islam, these men will never see heaven.
It is not enough that these so-called sheikhs defame hardworking women who want to help support their families. Now they are going after their husbands, fathers and brothers who encourage and support the women in their families to work as nurses.
It’s an affront to any human being to have religious men in a position of trust and authority defame individuals simply because they need financial support from female members of their families or want their women to take advantage of opportunities available to them.
This recent social media diatribe comes from a so-called sheikh who wrote that no man with honor or a sense of pride would allow his daughter to work in a mixed environment in the health sector.
What makes these statements so heinous is this guy has thousands of followers on Twitter. Many followers, I assume, imagine this individual as a role model. Do his followers see through this alleged sheikh’s (I can’t bring myself to call him a religious man) nonsense? The unfortunate answer is no. It’s likely some of his followers are uneducated, and their response is to follow his tweet to the letter and make the lives of the women in their families a living hell.
This obscene attitude toward nursing is personally offensive to me since I teach nursing students at King Saud bin Abdulaziz University for Health Sciences, Nursing College. His assessment that weak men allow their daughters to work in medical facilities that he considers no more than brothels reminds me of an incident that affected us all at the university.
A father had come to the university campus and asked to speak to our dean. He identified himself as the father of one of the nursing students. He wanted to take her out of the university because he believed that working in a mixed environment in a hospital was sinful. The dean replied that the man’s daughter was one of her best and brightest students. She reminded the father that it was up to the student to submit a formal resignation from the program.
The father, who was not living with his family, left the campus. A few days later he brought dinner to the family home. The daughter was excited to see her father. She brought him to the guest room and served the dinner. The father asked for a knife to cut lemons. When he was alone with her, he locked the door of the guest room and attacked her with the knife. The girl attempted to escape through a window while her mother and uncle heard her screams and attempted to break down the door. The father repeatedly stabbed his daughter, who died a short while later in the hospital.
We don’t know who the followers are of this so-called sheikh. Some could very well be troubled individuals like the father who murdered his daughter. The sheikh, in essence by condemning the nursing profession, is giving license to those troubled individuals to do as they please. The sheikh is making statements without understanding or thinking about the consequences of his remarks and the impact it would have on troubled individuals.
The Saudi government and educators are attempting to change the taboo of working in the nursing profession. The government has acknowledged the country is in desperate need of nursing professionals in the health care industry. The government is spending billions of riyals to develop this field. Yet the very men who should support the government’s efforts are sending a message that Saudi women are corrupted and the government is running a brothel, not an institution to give care to the ill, infirm and dying.
Dr. Sabah Abu Zinadah, a nursing consultant, recently filed a complaint against the sheikh who posted on the social media defaming and stigmatizing the nursing profession. It is now in the government’s hands whether to punish defamers who insist on labeling dedicated women as having loose morals by enforcing the Kingdom’s new cyber crime prevention act. If the new law truly has teeth, then the defamers must face the consequences of their actions.